American Library Association
The ALA puts out several lists annually. Titles are nominated by teens, teachers, and librarians.
Reading Rants: Out of the Ordinary Teen Booklists
Check out the categories: “Bare Bones,” Boy Meets Book,” and others. Books are reviewed
by site author, Jennifer Hubert.
Genrefluent (teens version of Genreflecting)
Book reviews and "Books of the Week" categorized by genre.
Teen Reads
Reviews are updated monthly. Good place to find new releases.
Novel List
You need a public library card to access. Click on "research databases" and scroll down to "Novel List" to search for books by topic of story and read reviews.
Review and React
Site created by Buffalo Schools, inviting students to share reactions and reviews about books they are reading.
The LYRE Review at YSU
Student reviews submitted from local school districts.
Teens Read Too
Reviews, author links, and more.
Teen Link from NYPL
Click on more books for a good list of suggested titles.

For Nonfiction
  American Library Association's nonfiction list from Teen Read Week
  American Library Association's Outstanding Books for the College Bound